BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA
NY STYLE PIZZA
$11.80
12" Medium
$14.35
14" Large
$16.80
16" Extra Large
$5.50
8" Personal
EACH TOPPING
$1.65
12" Medium
$1.95
14" Large
$2.25
16" Extra Large
$0.60
8" Personal
GLUTEN FREE-ISH
$3.35
14" Large
10 INCH CAULIFLOUR CRUST
$1.10
10" Medium
TOPPINGS
Pepperoni
Ground Beef
Meatballs
Sausage
Bacon
Canadian Bacon
Pastrami
Basil
Grilled Chicken
Mushrooms
Black Olives
Green Peppers
Onions
Red Onions
Salami
Buffalo Chicken
Pineapple
Extra Cheese
Spinach
Roma Tomatoes
Banana Peppers
Jalapeños
Cheddar Cheese
Buffalo Pepperoni
SPECIALTY PIZZAS
WHITE PIE
NY Style Crust with White Pie Sauce (Ricotta, Garlic and Herbs), Roma Tomatoes,
Sliced Mozzarella and Fresh Basil
Try it with Balsamic Glaze
$15.50
12" Medium
$17.85
14" Large
$20.50
16" Extra Large
$6.99
8" Personal
CARNIVORE (MEAT)
NY Style Crust with Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Sausage, Ground Beef, Salami, Pastrami, and Canadian Bacon
$16.55
12" Medium
$18.95
14" Large
$21.50
16" Extra Large
$7.55
8" Personal
HERBIVORE (VEGGIE)
NY Style Crust with Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Roma Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Onions,
Green Peppers and Black Olives
$14.95
12" Medium
$17.50
14" Large
$19.99
16" Extra Large
$6.99
8" Personal
OMNIVORE [WORKS]
NY Style Crust with Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Sausage, Ground Beef, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers and Black Olives
$15.95
12" Medium
$18.50
14" Large
$20.85
16" Extra Large
$7.55
8" Personal
BIG KAHUNA PIE
NY Style Crust with Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Canadian Bacon and Pineapple
Try it with Luau Sauce instead of Honey Cream
$14.50
12" Medium
$16.85
14" Large
$19.50
16" Extra Large
$6.55
8" Personal
MARGHERITA PIE
NY Style Crust with Tomato Sauce, Roma Tomatoes, Sliced Mozzarella and Fresh Basil
$14.85
12" Medium
$17.50
14" Large
$19.99
16" Extra Large
$6.55
8" Personal
BBQ CHICKEN PIE
NY Style Crust with Texas BBQ Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Bacon, Grilled Chicken and Red Onions
$15.50
12" Medium
$17.85
14" Large
$20.50
16" Extra Large
$6.99
8" Personal
GRAHAM SLAM
NY Style Crust with Buffalo Mild Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Bacon and Buffalo Chicken
$15.50
12" Medium
$17.85
14" Large
$20.50
16" Extra Large
$6.99
8" Personal
SPICY ITALIAN
NY Style Crust with Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Buffalo Pepperoni, Salami, Canadian Bacon, Red Onions, Banana Peppers, and Pie Guys Pepper Sauce
$15.50
12" Medium
$17.85
14" Large
$20.50
16" Extra Large
$6.99
8" Personal
BBQ BACON CHEESEBURGER
NY Style Crust with Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Bacon, Beef, Diced Pickles,
Cheddar Cheese, and Texas BBQ Sauce
$16.55
12" Medium
$18.95
14" Large
$21.50
16" Extra Large
$7.50
8" Personal
CUBAN
NY Style Crust with Mustard Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Bacon, Canadian Bacon, and Diced Pickles
$14.50
12" Medium
$16.85
14" Large
$19.50
16" Extra Large
$6.55
8" Personal
All Pizzas are served with Honey Cream (Thank You Upper Crust Pizza 1996-2015 for the recipe)
Order any Specialty Pizza in Gluten Free or Cauliflower Crust.
WINGS
JUMBO WINGS
Buffalo Mild, Buffalo Hot, Garlic Parmesan, Fiery Garlic Parm, Asian Chili, Texas BBQ,
Lexington BBQ, Luau, or Plain. Served with Ranch or Blue Cheese and Celery
All drums and flats add $0.75 and $1.50
$8.75
5 Wings
$15.75
10 Wings
BONELESS WINGS
Buffalo Mild, Buffalo Hot, Garlic Parmesan, Fiery Garlic Parm, Asian Chili, Texas BBQ,
Lexington BBQ, or Plain. Served with Ranch or Blue Cheese and Celery
$7.50
6 Wings
$13.50
12 Wings
APPETIZERS
GARLIC CHEESE BREAD
$5.00
6 Pieces
$8.00
12 Pieces
NY Style Dough Smothered in Garlic Butter and Mozzarella Cheese. Served with a Side of Marinara
GARLIC KNOTS
$4.00
6 Knots
$7.00
12 Knots
Hand Knotted Strips of Our Dough Baked Golden Brown and Tossed In Garlic Butter.
Sprinkled with Parmesan and Served with a Side of Marinara.
STROMBOLI SANDWICHES - $8.65
THE SICILIAN
Pepperoni, Canadian Bacon, Salami, Banana Peppers, Mozzarella, Pie Guy's Pepper Sauce
Served with a side of Marinara
JALAPENO CHICKEN POPPER
Chicken, Cream Cheese, Bacon, Jalapenos, Cheddar, Pie Guy's Pepper Sauce
Served with a side of Ranch
BUFFALO MAC
Buffalo Chicken, Mozzarella, Cheddar, Mild Sauce
Served with a side of Blue Cheese
SALADS & SANDWICHES
SALADS & SANDWICHES HAVE RETURNED TO PIE GUYS ALL SANDWICHES - $10.00
Philly cheese steak
Grilled Steak, Mushrooms, Green Peppers and Onions Topped with Provolone Cheese and Served on a Toasted Hoagie Roll with Chips, Pickle and a Side of Steakhouse Sauce.
Meatball Marinara
Fontanini Meatballs in our House Made Marinara On a Toasted Sub Roll with Melted Provolone Cheese. Served with Chips and a Pickle
CLUB
Chicken , Ham, Bacon and Mixed Cheese, serve on a Toasted Bread then Topped with lettuce, Tomatoes and Mayo Serve with Chips and Pickles
FAJITA CHICKEN
Seasoned Grilled Chicken With Onions,Peppers, Cheese Blend on a Toasted Bread, Served with side of Spicy Mayo, Pickles and Chips.
CHICKEN Cheese Steak
Seasoned Grilled Chicken, Onions, Mushrooms, Green Pepper, Provolone, Serve with Chips and Pickle
DESSERTS
MINI CANNOLIS
Two or Four Crisp Mini Cannoli Shells filled with Sweetened Ricotta Cheese and Chocolate Chips, Dusted with Powdered Sugar and Drizzled with Chocolate Sauce
Two - $4.75 Four - $8.75
CINNAMON KNOTS
$4.00
6 Knots
$7.00
12 Knots
Hand Knotted Strips of Our Dough Tossed in Cinnamon, Sugar, and Butter then Baked Golden Brown and Served with a Side of our Honey Cream Dipping Sauce
MORAVIAN SUGAR CAKE PIE
"Fluffy" Version of Our Dough Topped with Sweetened Cream Cheese, Brown Sugar,
Cinnamon and Butter
$8.75
10" pie
PINEAPPLE INSIDE DOWN DESSERT CALZONE
Our Dough Topped with Sweetened Cream Cheese and a Cherry Pineapple Mix which is then Folded Over and Covered with Cinnamon Sugar and Butter
$8.75
12" calzone
COOKIES'N CREME DESSERT CALZONE
Our Dough Topped with Sweetened Cream Cheese and Chocolate Cookie Crumbles which is then Folded Over and Covered with Sugar and Butter
$8.75
12" calzone
S'More Crunch Pie
Our 10 inch "fluffy" version of Our Dough, Moravian Cream Mix with Chocolate Chips, Marshmallow and a Topping of Graham Crackers.
$8.75
10" pie
ASSORTED BUNDT CAKES
3" Moist Cake Topped with Sweet Icing
Order Online or Ask a Cashier about Available Flavors
$3.00
SEASONAL DESSERT PIE
PUMPKIN PIE CRUNCH
"Fluffy" Version of Our Dough Topped with Sweetened Cream Cheese, Pumpkin Pie Filling,
Cinnamon Swirl and Pecan Streusel Topping
$8.75
10" pie
DRINKS
16oz BOTTLED SOFT DRINKS
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper, Cheerwine, A&W Root Beer
$1.99
TWO LITER SOFT DRINKS
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper, Cheerwine, A&W Root Beer
$2.80
BOTTLED WATER
$1.35
SOFT DRINKS AND TEA
2.50